Forget the wine list: this is what really matters in aged care

By

After touring 15 aged care homes for her mother, I discovered that staffing, management and location mattered far more than luxury extras.

How I chose an aged care home for my mother

When I went shopping for a residential aged-care room for my mother, Rosemary, a geriatrician gave me some useful advice.

Luxury aged care dining setting beside a nurse holding an elderly resident's hand, highlighting the importance of quality care and staffing.

The doctor said to visit a wide range of places and find one that is close to home so visiting her is easy.

Rosemary had accelerating vascular dementia and the home carers said she couldn't live alone. If I left it too late, she would end up in hospital from a fall, then probably be sent to an aged-care home care with a vacancy that could be a long way from me.

Pools, theatres and wine lists: the aged care sales pitch

I made appointments and booked tours, visiting around 15 aged-care homes in a 12-kilometre radius.

I inspected luxurious, for-profit institutions as well as homely nursing homes tied to religious groups.

I checked out no-frills homes with shared beds in the one room, set up like a hospital ward.

However this type of setup is no longer common because of resident privacy, dignity, infection control and consumer demand.

I looked at large care homes, with one accommodating 160 residents, and many medium-sized ones with 100 beds or fewer and some small facilities with a few dozen beds.

Each had its own sales pitch.

Some had busy diversional therapy programs with outings and inhouse activities most days. Some had chapels or churches across the courtyard.

The expensive ones had foyers like an upmarket hotel.

One had an indoor swimming pool for hydrotherapy treatments. A harpist played for residents at lunch time, at another. A new one, still being built, offered a theatre for movies and small concerts. It had sub penthouse suites and a wine list at dinner.

Questions to ask when touring an aged care home

  • How long has the manager been here?
  • What is staff turnover like?
  • Are meals prepared on site?
  • What activities run each week?
  • How long is the waiting list?
  • How many staff are rostered overnight?
  • Are rooms currently available?

What aged care providers show you, and what they don't

Residential aged-care homes of a certain size had in-house cafes with limited hours.

They offered hairdressing salons, libraries, pianos, free internet and landscaped outdoor areas. While most prepared the meals on site, others trucked in snap-frozen meals.

Some of the homes were old and tatty with poor airflow. Some of the newer ones had better ventilation.

I tried to get a sense of the quality of the care. Just as the school principal is important, so too is the aged-care manager.

Why staffing matters more than luxury features

Visiting at lunchtime means you can witness the other residents out of their rooms, the number of staff and the quality of food.

The deciding factor came down to the cost and staffing.

Are there enough staff at critical times, and are their working conditions, including training and supervision, positive?

Ideally you need to observe staffing as an anonymous visitor, rather than during a promotional walk through with management.

How much does an aged care room cost?

The cost of an aged-care bed varies widely, depending on where you live.

Best Aged Care Australia publishes a national median range of a lump sum or refundable accommodation deposit (RAD) of $325,000 to $1,437,000, but I have seen prices for some luxury homes of more than $2 million.

You can always try negotiating with the manager for a lower price as I did.

There is a RAD cap of $750,000 before the provider must apply to the Aged Care Pricing Commissioner for permission. It says the median RAD for Canberra and Sydney is $719,000, while Melbourne is $660,000.

Aged care costs at a glance

  • National median RAD range: $325,000 to $1.437 million
  • Sydney median RAD: $719,000
  • Canberra median RAD: $719,000
  • Melbourne median RAD: $660,000
  • Some luxury homes charge more than $2 million

The biggest problem? Finding a bed at all

It took me weeks to visit all the homes.

The bad news was that most nursing homes in my area had no vacancies and a waiting list, especially the well-priced, cheerful aged-care homes with a friendly, competent manager who had run the centre for many years.

This is what makes shopping for aged care hard.

There is increased demand for aged care as the population ages. Some 260,772 people received residential aged care in Australia during the 2024-25 financial year from 636 providers, according to KPMG's annual aged-care market analysis released this year.

Start the search earlier than you think

About one in five Australians older than 80 and one in 20 older than 65 are in residential aged care, even though for many that won't be what they planned.

This means it is a good idea to start the long process rolling as soon as you think your parents need aged care.

This isn't easy because ageing parents often don't want to go into care until there is an emergency or severe cognitive and physical decline.

In my immediate area, we are short of aged-care beds. Some of the small, aged-care providers are changing their business model and exiting aged care.

A 66-bed affordable nursing home around the corner from me that offers single, double and multiple bedrooms is being redeveloped into a boarding house with micro apartments and no age limits, renting to young professionals.

Government policy has not helped.

A tightening of aged-care regulations several years ago has meant those with fewer than 100 beds are unlikely to be viable, and the business of residential aged care is less profitable.

These smaller sites are often transitioning to residential development and government zoning changes to preserve existing residential aged-care sites and incorporating residential aged care beds in State housing targets would really help this shortage.

Get stories like this in our newsletters.

Related Stories

TAGS

Susan Hely has contributed to Money for more than 15 years. She has been a finance journalist for more than three decades, beginning at the Australian Financial Review before moving to the Sydney Morning Herald. Susan edited Superfunds magazine for the Association of Superannuation Funds of Australia, and writes regularly on family money and superannuation. She's also author of the best-selling book Women and Money. Connect with Susan Hely on LinkedIn.