Should you buy, hold or sell GrainCorp shares?
GrainCorp (GNC) is a diversified agribusiness. It is the third-largest food production business listed on the ASX and the largest grain storage and handling company on the east coast of Australia. It is also a crusher and refiner of oilseed and a refiner of edible fats and oil.
Over the past 12 months the share price has fluctuated but ended up rising by about 3%. They also deliver a 7.6% dividend yield, which is fully franked.
This was broadly in line with the market with the S&P/ASX 300 index generating a total return of 10.1%.
What did GrainCorp's full year results show?
They released their 2023 full year (FY23) results in mid-November (they have a September 30 year-end) and surprised the market with a better-than-expected result. Profits in FY23 were well below those in FY22, however this was expected as FY22 saw a bumper harvest, the second largest on record.
The crop in 2023 was still very strong, and revenue, earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation (EBITDA), earnings per share (EPS) and dividends were all above expectations.
Breaking the results down further, GrainCorp's business is divided into two main segments: Agribusiness and Processing.
The Agribusiness segment is dominated by grain storage and handling with the largest network on the East Coast of Australia. They have 160 regional receiving sites and seven bulk ports, all connected by road and rail infrastructure.
The Processing segment is primarily involved in the refining of edible fats and oils. They are a leading oilseed crusher and refiner in Australia. The segment also includes Animal Nutrition. They are the largest canola meal producers and a supplier of vegetable oil and molasses-based feed supplements.
The results for the two segments moved in opposite directions in FY23. Agribusiness is the largest component with an EBITDA of $401 million. This was down 36% on the prior year. Total grain handled fell to 37.4 million metric tonnes (mmt) from 41.1 mmt in FY22.
The EBITDA for Processing of $153m, was up 20% on the prior year. This was on the back of improved performance of oilseed crushing, increasing throughput volume from 471 thousand metric tonnes (kmt) to 496 kmt, the fifth year in a row that throughput volume increased.
Is GrainCorp a quality stock?
The Stockopedia Quality score for GrainCorp is high at 93. It is supported by a strong balance sheet and strong cash flow. The cash balance leaped to $735 million this year on the back of strong cash earnings and the divestment of United Malt Group.
GrainCorp received $127 million from the sale of their 8.5% stake in United Malt Group which completed its sale to Malteries Soufflet last November and has now been delisted.
This provides a sizable war chest for GrainCorp's management who are now in the enviable position of being able to both invest for growth as well as reward shareholders.
How much are GrainCorp dividends paying?
Dividends were retained at 54 cents for the financial year, the same as last year, despite the drop in net profit. The dividends are fully franked.
This includes 26 cents of special dividends to take account of the cyclicality of earnings. Last year's special dividend component was 28 cents.
Structuring dividends this way helps to manage expectations. Market analysts are forecasting dividends per share for FY24 of 31 cents which would represent growth of 10% based on the ordinary component of the dividend.
What does the GrainCorp share buyback mean?
In addition to dividends, management announced a $50 million on-market buy-back.
GrainCorp are using some of this honey pot to invest for growth. They invested $35 million in the acquisition of an Animal Nutrition business. They are also making investments in digital and agtech, as well as assessing investments in additional crushing capacity.
But the big ticket item that is currently being evaluated is an investment in a seed-crushing plant to create biofuels. They are considering a new oilseed crushing plant in Western Australia to crush excess canola seeds from local farmers to create biofuels.
At present, excess canola seeds are exported and processed into biofuels overseas. Bringing some of this capacity onshore would have benefits in terms of domestic renewable energy security. The plant would have a crushing capacity of 750 kmt to 1 mmt and cost several hundred million dollars to build.
They are already in discussions with airport operators IFM Investors about using the generated biofuel for aviation purposes. Further feasibility work is required before they make a final decision on the investment.
What is the outlook for GrainCorp shares?
GrainCorp also has a high Stockopedia Value score at 96. When compared with the FY23 results, all the value metrics, such as the PE ratio, Price to Book Value ratio and Price to Sales ratio, appear cheap.
However, the picture changes a little when looking at the forecast numbers. Given the cyclical nature of the business, there is an expectation that revenue and earnings will fall sharply in FY24 and even further in FY25. The PE ratio measured against FY25 forecast EPS is 16.5.
That said, forecasts are inherently uncertain, especially when it comes to forecasting commodity prices and events of nature. GrainCorp surprised on the upside this year and may well do so again in future years. They are also working on strategies to try and smooth out some of the cyclicality in their earnings.
GrainCorp has delivered very good results over the past few years. While a lot of this has been due to bumper harvests, they have also been able to improve efficiency as well as diversify their earnings base. They are now in a strong position to use their balance sheet capacity to extend this further and keep the business on a solid footing.
Get stories like this in our newsletters.
