Why now is the time to hold BHP shares


As one of the largest and oldest listed mining companies in the world, BHP Group is probably well known to most Australians, indeed many would hold an interest in the company's shares via their investments or superannuation.

Formerly known as 'the Big Australian', BHP's origins date back to 1885 where it began life as the Broken Hill Proprietary Company, a silver and lead miner at Broken Hill in western New South Wales.

Over its lifetime it has undergone a number of name changes, mergers and demergers to become BHP today, a global miner operating in multiple locations across the globe and producing a variety of key commodities such as iron ore, copper, nickel, coal and oil.

bhp buyback

Further change is afoot with a number of recent proposals announced by the company and approved by shareholders, to simplify its structure and focus its portfolio on future facing commodities that help both global growth and decarbonisation. These changes can be summarised as follows.

  • The unification of BHPs corporate structure to a single listing in Australia. Currently BHP is dual listed in the UK and Australia due to its merger with UK listed Billiton mining company back in 2021.
  • A demerger of BHP's petroleum business which will be merged with Woodside Petroleum to create one of the world's largest oil exploration and production companies.
  • The sale and exit of its thermal coal assets (the type used to generate electricity) to leave only metallurgical coal assets (the type used to produce steel).
  • Further investments in potash, used to produce fertiliser for food production and Nickel, earmarked by the company as a core decarbonising commodity.

Following these changes, BHP will become a resources company focused on supporting global growth and decarbonisation. BHP's iron ore business and its high-quality metallurgical coal assets, will contribute the majority of revenue, approximately 70%, which will contribute vital inputs for the steelmaking industry, a key component for infrastructure and urbanisation.

The growing global demand for food will be supported by BHPs investment in potash, used for fertiliser, to provide a future revenue stream for the company. Finally, the remainder of the portfolio, approximately 30% of revenue will be made up of copper and nickel both of which are key commodities in the global decarbonisation pathway.


BHP has traded in line with the broader market over the past 10 years with annualised total returns of 10.7% per annum compared to a return of 11.9% per annum for the S&P ASX200.

The stock price return is only 3% per annum, with much of the total return coming from dividends payments. BHP is currently yielding 8.7% net and 12.4% when grossed up for franking credits based on dividends, which are expected to be paid in February and August.

This high dividend yield is a function of recently improved profitability due to the high prices received for its iron ore production. Profits doubled in 2021 and BHP currently pay 70% of this profit out as dividends to shareholders.

Profits are expected to remain at these levels into financial year 2022, with future growth coming from investments in potash and an expected uptick in demand for copper and nickel as the transition to Net Zero gains momentum.


The recently announced changes will offer investors the chance to re-evaluate their holdings and view of BHP. For passive investors, index funds will now be forced to increase their holdings as the market capitalisation of the UK listing comes back to Australia, effectively upweighting the stock from approximately 6.5% to 10%, making it the largest company in the index once again.

For sustainably conscious investors, the demerging of the petroleum business and the sale of the electricity producing coal assets makes BHP potentially more investable from an environmental perspective. Indeed, a holding in BHP will give investors an early supply chain exposure to the decarbonisation of the planet, where copper and nickel will be a major input into renewable energy infrastructure and storage.

ESG considerations

Mining is often cited as an industry that has the greatest exposure to Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) risks. Problems specific to mining include environmental issues such as resource use (land, water), waste management and emissions, and social issues such as child labour, human rights violations, corruption and workplace safety.

These can have huge reputational and financial implications for miners and are key risks for investors. Unfortunately, BHP is no stranger to these issues due to it part ownership of the Samarco Dam in Brazil, which failed in 2015, killing 19 people, displacing hundreds and creating widespread environmental damage.

As one of the largest global miners, BHP is under increased scrutiny and the investing community looks to companies like BHP to lead the way for higher ESG standards given these obvious risks. Aside from this disaster, BHP does score well in areas such as governance, diversity, and emissions reduction and overall, scores above average on most metrics.

Recommendation - Hold

We currently rate BHP as a hold. There should be some short-term support for the stock, from marginal buyers such as index funds and sustainable investors looking to revisit the stock after its fossil fuel divestments.

BHP scores well on our growth and quality metrics, with a solid balance sheet and strong cashflow generation, which is supported by a favourable pricing environment for its key commodities, albeit a potentially volatile one.

The proceeds from the asset sales to Woodside will be distributed as an in specie fully franked dividend, this is especially attractive to non-tax paying investors such as retirees, who will fully benefit from the franking credits.

Going forward, there is also the possibility of increased dividend payouts as the business requires less capital for the petroleum business. This could also mean an increased potential for capital management initiatives such as share buybacks, which are also particularly attractive to low tax paying shareholders.

Get stories like this in our newsletters.

Related Stories


Toby Bellingham is a portfolio trader and portfolio manager with Redpoint Investment Management. He has a Masters in Applied Finance from Macquarie University and an Investment Management Certificate.