Australians saved hard - why do they still fear retirement?

Australians saved for decades for retirement, so why do so many still fear running out of money?

Australia's retirement story is changing quickly and testing the foundations of our retirement system.

In the year 2000, the average retirement age in Australia was 61 for men and 59 for women. Two decades on, and it has shifted later and narrowed to 65 for men and 64 for women.

Our life expectancy has increased, and the number of years we spend in retirement is getting longer, 20 years for men and 25 years for women.

We are working longer and living longer, a pattern seen across the developed world.

However, one thing has remained stubbornly constant over this time: for people nearing retirement, there is significant uncertainty about how many years of retirement their superannuation will need to fund.

Retirement, after all, is personal; you don't look at averages when it comes to your life and your needs. And when you layer in the current global economic and market volatility, these concerns are heightened.

The latest Challenger Retirement Happiness Index research found cost of living (57%), financial security (54%), and running out of money in retirement (46%) were the top concerns for Australians aged 60 and over.

Today's retirees are the first generation to have built significant superannuation savings.

Yet half of Australians aged 60+ still say they feel financially insecure. After decades of focusing on saving, when we retire the challenge changes from how much we have saved and accumulated to how much income those savings will need to deliver to last for the rest of our lives, however long that may be.

With retirement now spanning decades, small miscalculations compound.

Underestimate your how long you'll live, ignore inflation, or misjudge market returns, and the consequences can be significant.

Indeed, in March 2021, the RBA forecast inflation to lead to a 9% increase in prices; in fact, we've actually experienced a 21% increase. That translates to a stark choice for an average retiree: either draw down more income or live a life less full.

It's not all gloomy, though; our research also shows that those retirees who have a plan have greater confidence.

The plan doesn't need to be perfect; it just needs to provide some lights to guide the way and to allow people to avoid being overwhelmed when inevitable changes occur.

Working longer is not the solution

One interpretation of rising retirement age is that Australians are solving the problem by simply working longer.

To a degree, this is true. Extended workforce participation can strengthen savings, reduce drawdown years, and boost overall retirement resilience.

Staying in the workforce can also extend the ability to remain connected and to retain a sense of purpose, two areas that have a major positive impact on retirement wellbeing.

But working longer is not universally available. Health constraints, caregiving responsibilities, industry dynamics, and age discrimination limit choice. Many don't choose when to retire; it is thrust upon them.

Retiring at 65 still leaves, on average, two decades of income to fund. The bigger structural point is this: retirement planning remains framed around accumulation, not decumulation.

Around 780 Australians retire every day, however, the vast majority are not transitioning to solutions designed for this stage of life.

We know nearly four in five Australians aged 60+ (76%) would be much happier if they had a guaranteed income for life in retirement.

Yet, more than half of all Australians 60+ (59%) do not know about, or haven't heard of, lifetime income streams as a financial strategy for retirement.

Australia's compulsory superannuation system has been a global success in building retirement savings pools.

But behavioural biases and legacy product designs make converting those pools of retirement savings into sustainable lifetime income an ongoing challenge.

The next evolution of the system can move from a focus on raising balances, to a critical focus on managing longevity and income certainty.

Redesigning retirement

After decades of savings, we are asking retirees to do something that feels completely counter-intuitive - to start spending. A clear knowledge gap persists that needs to be overcome.

First, we must reframe conversations around longevity explicitly. Australians understand market volatility. They feel inflation.

But many still underestimate how long retirement lasts - and how to safely spend across decades.

Second, retirement strategies need to become more tailored and accessible. Blended solutions that include guaranteed income components are likely to play an increasingly important role.

Third, advice matters more than ever. Happiness in retirement correlates strongly with those who have received advice.

Yet advice accessibility remains uneven. If nearly half of Australians feel unprepared, ensuring greater access to advice or some form of guidance - whether digital, hybrid, or traditional - becomes critical.

Finally, behavioural challenges need to be acknowledged and addressed. Almost half of those surveyed expect an income shortfall.

However, research by the Grattan Institute found 65% of retirees super balances in Account Based Pensions remained unspent by the average life expectancy. Expectation shapes retirement behaviour - often towards underspending, over-caution, leading to a reduced quality of life.

A defining decade

Australia stands at an inflection point.

The first generation to retire with substantial super balances is transitioning from savings to spending. Their experience will shape expectations for those who follow.

If nearly half anticipate an income gap, and close to half feel unprepared, we should assume accumulation success will not automatically translate into retirement confidence.

We have built one of the most effective accumulation frameworks in the world. But adequacy at retirement is only the beginning.

The real test is can those balances be converted into reliable, sustainable income for 20 to 25 years or more, through inflation cycles, market downturns, and rising health and living costs, and the resulting increase in retirement confidence.

The next decade will determine whether Australia simply produces retirees with large balances or if we deliver Australians a retirement they can enjoy confidently and happily.

Get stories like this in our newsletters.