Ask Paul: The card surcharge ban is killing my business

By

An Aussie travel agent says the card surcharge ban is costing them thousands in fees on a single customer booking. Is the policy flawed or just a cost of doing business?

Reader question

We own our own small travel business as a franchise. With the new credit card fee surcharge rules, is anyone considering the effect on travel industries and similar businesses?

a photo of paul clitheroe (left) with a stock photo of a small business owner

Clients want to use credit cards to pay for trips so they can access free insurances or points. The card fee of up to 2% cannot be passed on, so it needs to be absorbed by the travel agent.

As a holiday may cost between $50,000-$100,000 and an agent may get 5%-15% as commission, this will reduce the business's margins significantly as most of the price is destined for other businesses.

A $100,000 booking at 5% commission is $5000 for the agent - a percentage of this has to be paid to the franchise.

We are then left with paying up to $2000 in credit card fees, which we cannot pass on. Previously we were able to be transparent about fees and our clients could choose a method that suited them. As we won't be reimbursed, we will have to raise prices and perhaps offer a discount for cash/savings purchase.

Unfortunately, a lot of travel is instant purchase. Clients will not be able to hold products while awaiting funds to clear so a bank transfer won't work.

This will either lead small businesses like mine to close down or an increase in inflation because this policy will mean businesses will put their prices up by 2% to ensure they can capture this cost.

What do you suggest? - Matthew

Paul's response

Here you have me on the hop, Matthew.

I know no more about travel products than any other consumer, but from your numbers I can see that a $100,000 holiday (which is a very large amount!) generating $5000 for you, less franchise fees, less $2000 in card fees you need to carry is not viable.

What I am thinking is we are dealing with the wrong travel agent (just joking, but with apologies to our travel agent, whose services we much appreciate).

But looking at holidays we have planned with them over the past decade, we have the option of a 2% fee on Visa or Mastercard, a little more than 3% on American Express.

I thought this was normal for most businesses these days (unless they are selling a high-margin product). I find that these fees are far higher than the value of the points I get, so we do a bank transfer anyway.

I would hope your clients would understand that holidays increase with inflation and a service fee on a credit card is hardly anything new.

But I do agree, we all like something for nothing, but I don't see how this can work for you as a business based on the numbers you have given me.

Where this looks hard to me is for a small transaction retailer, say a coffee shop.

It looks like they must increase a coffee from, say, $5 to $5.05 to cover the costs if customers are using a Visa or other card because a surcharge is no longer allowed.

Obviously they can also offer the same coffee for $5 cash. Frankly, we all know we end up paying closer to $5.05 for a $5 coffee anyway, so I don't see much change in consumer behaviour here.

But with the bigger amounts involved in travel, I would hope your franchisor can provide useful advice.

This same issue impacts you all. The RBA has capped interchange fees at 0.3%.

This should help as they were up to 1.5%. Then you have the card scheme fee of about 0.1% and payment provider fee of between 0.1% and 0.5%, the larger the turnover, the lower this payment is.

Obviously, I have no idea how your head office handles this, but as you point out, this is a critical issue for you and must be for others in the franchise.

It seems to me that with big volume, a large group should be able to get total costs to less than 1%.

I do understand your point about 'instant purchase', and I agree that consumers are irrationally attached to frequent flyer points, which in my opinion are about the fastest depreciating asset on our planet. I'll be interested to see how this pans out.

I, for one, will not have any issue if our travel agent needs around a 1% increase in prices if I want to use a credit card.

I reckon that is far better than paying the current 2% and getting basically useless points.

I suspect a fee-free bank transfer will be my and most people's cost-effective option.

What to read next

Get stories like this in our newsletters.

Related Stories

Paul Clitheroe AM is the founder of Money and serves as the publication's editorial adviser. One of Australia's most trusted personal finance experts, Paul has spent decades helping Australians build wealth, manage debt and make smarter money decisions. He is widely known for host­ing the Money TV program and authoring best-selling personal finance books. Since launching Money in 1999, he has played a leading role in delivering practical, independent financial guidance to Australians. Paul is chair of InvestSMART Financial Services. He was the founding chair of Ecstra Foundation, a national not-for-profit focused on improving financial wellbeing, from 2018 to 2026, and led the Australian Government's Financial Literacy Board and Financial Literacy Australia from 2004 to 2019. In academia, Paul is chair in financial literacy at Macquarie University, where he is also a Professor in the School of Business and Economics. Ask Paul your money question. Due to volume, Paul cannot respond to questions posted in the comments section.