Housing policies: What are Labor and the Coalition proposing?

By

Home ownership has emerged as a major battle zone in the federal election, with both parties pitching a range of measures to help first home buyers take that difficult first step into the property market.

The policies mostly seek to overcome the two main hurdles to home ownership - the difficulty of saving a deposit as house prices keep rising and the difficulty of meeting loan repayments.

Here's how they compare.

housing-policies-2025-federal-election

Labor housing policies

Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has promised to help first home buyers to purchase a property with just a 5% deposit rather than the standard 20%.

Labor's plan involves expanding its existing First Home Buyers Guarantee scheme - where the government acts as a guarantor on the loan and so does away with the need for mortgage insurance - to make it available to all first-time home buyers.

However, it would only be available to buyers of homes under the median home price for each capital city.

It has also committed $10 billion to support the building of 100,000 new homes for first home buyers, consisting of $2 billion worth of grants and $8 billion worth of zero-interest loans.

Labor has already introduced a shared equity scheme due to start later this year.

Under the Help to Buy program, the federal government will co-buy properties with individuals, purchasing 30% for existing and 40% for new homes.

It is allocating 10,000 places a year for four years and the program will be available to singles who earn up to $100,000 and couples and single parents who earn up to $160,000.

Participants can repay the money over time or when they sell the property.

Coalition housing policies

Liberal Party leader Peter Dutton is planning to give first-time home buyers a tax deduction for some of the interest paid on their home loan, but only if it is for a newly-built home.

Home buyers could deduct interest payments on up to $650,000 of their mortgage from their income taxes for five years.

The scheme will be means-tested at $175,000 for singles and $250,000 for couples and will only be available while the recipient is living in the home.

The Coalition is also planning to modify the First Home Buyers Guarantee scheme - lifting the income cap from $125,000 to $175,000 for singles and from $200,000 to $250,000 for couples.

The policies announced on Sunday are in addition to existing policies.

It plans to allow first-time home buyers to withdraw up to $50,000 from their superannuation account to help with their deposit, with the money to be repaid when the house is sold.

It will also direct the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA), which oversees the financial stability of the banking system, to weaken home loan serviceability test for first home buyers, cutting the required loan serviceability buffer from 3 percentage points to 2.5 percentage points.

The coalition is also promising $5 billion in infrastructure investment to unlock 500,000 new homes by funding water, power and sewerage.

What do the experts think?

Both parties' policies have been condemned by economists, who say that putting more money in the pockets of first home buyers will lead to even higher home prices by fuelling demand, and that the Liberal's plan will be a major drain on the federal budget.

Most policies won't create any new houses, although Joe Moloney, deputy program director of the Grattan Institute's housing and economic security program, says Labor's $10 billion home fund is a supply-side policy.

But he said raising the personal income caps for Labor's First Home Buyers Guarantee will probably extend help to people who mostly could have saved their own deposit anyway.

Moloney described Dutton's mortgage payment deductibility plan as bad policy that would help high income earners more than those on modest incomes, because tax deductions are worth more to people on higher incomes.

Under the scheme, a first home buyer with a taxable income of $120,000 with a $650,000 mortgage at 6.1% will receive a benefit of around $60,000. However, someone earning $250,000 would benefit by $87,000.

Get stories like this in our newsletters.

Related Stories

Christopher Niesche has more than 25 years experience in print journalism, starting with a staff position on The Australian newspaper, and then on the New Zealand Herald, Dow Jones Newswires and the Australian Financial Review. He has been a freelance business writer for the past decade. Christopher holds a Bachelor of Arts from The University of Sydney. Connect with him on LinkedIn.
Comments
Patrick Ward
April 23, 2025 6.27pm

I am glad to see you suggesting a young person breaking into the property market by buying a home and renting out the spare rooms. It was how I got myself into the house market back in 1980, having moved out from living with my parents, when they moved and still needed to finish off an apprenticeship. I shared a couple of places before, so leaned the art of how renting works. In the last 3 months of my apprenticeship I was sent up North of SA to get more experience. Accommodation and meals were part of the package so came back to Adelaide with a nice bank balance, plus a lot of experience looking after ones self. With my trade now under my belt, I transferred to another government agency with a depot in the Southern area of Adelaide.

I had saved nicely and had $4k in the bank, then borrowed $2k from my parents (yes bank of M&D was a thing then as well), l purchased an slightly run down home in the suburbs. Immediately I let out the spare room and began a crash course in being a landlord. With shift work I was able to pay my house off in 3yrs and 6mths. Was a great platform for our start. Yes I managed to get married at the end, not to one of my housemates I may add.

You may be wondering the price of that first home, $24,500 after knocking down the asking price $500. Yes how things have changed, but it was still hard work and dedication.

Patrick and Jenny. Aldinga Beach, South Australia.