Voluntary redundancy: Should you take the money and run?


Published on

Taking a voluntary redundancy during COVID-19, or at any time, needs careful consideration.

There are the financial implications, future employment prospects in your industry and the emotional and lifestyle aspects to think about. Often it will mean talking to a professional - an accountant, financial adviser or counsellor - to discuss your options.

The money can be enticing; generally, if you're made redundant after five years or more with the company, you're entitled to part of your long service entitlements, paid pro rata.

what you need to know about voluntary redundancy

In addition, you have set entitlements which, for many people, are listed on the Fair Work Ombudsman site.

Crunching the numbers

Mark McShane, senior financial adviser at Minchin Moore, says you might see the redundancy figure you are receiving but how does it match with the amount you need to live on?

"People need to know about the numbers - what their cost of living is now and into the future," says McShane.

There are also considerations of health and longevity or how long the money needs to last, he says.

Jenny Brown, chief executive and financial adviser at JBS Financial Strategists, says people need to understand their own budget before taking a voluntary redundancy.

"Understand what your budget is - what you spend, what your cash buffer is and how the payment fits with that," says Brown.

"If you are retiring early, know if you are able to access your super and whether you are eligible for Centrelink payments."

She says it's also important to have an idea of how long it will take you to find another job.

"Victoria is now facing 10% unemployment which is likely to go a lot higher, so look at how long it is likely to take to find work - three, six or 12 months," she says.

And age is another factor - generally, the older you get the longer it takes, she says.

It's about more than money

Executive career coach and strategist Heidi Winney says the most important consideration for anyone thinking about taking voluntary redundancy is the financial implication, and the next consideration is whether someone really dislikes working for the company and/or the manager.

"If they find that the "pain of staying is greater than the pain of leaving" then voluntary redundancy is ideal," says Winney.

"Having said that, there is no one perfect company or perfect manager and often people think that by leaving they're going to be in a much happier situation, which isn't always the case."

Consider the current job market

Winney says that in the current state of the labour market, with unemployment expected to rise further from around 9%, the competition when applying for jobs is very high and you can expect many hundreds of applicants for each role.

"With voluntary redundancy it can be tempting to take a large payout and take a risk in finding a new job and surprisingly many people are actually finding jobs in this market," she says.

However, finding a job is not always through job ads.

"The most important activity anyone considering voluntary redundancy needs to be comfortable with is the networking - those who are finding jobs in these more challenging times are finding them mostly through their network," she says.

People should also pay attention to changes in the economy.

Winney says if you're an employee who's considering taking voluntary redundancy yet have a role or are in a profession that's in demand (i.e. IT, healthcare, government, infrastructure, construction, and some parts of retail), you may be taking less risk in finding a new role.

"People have a better chance of finding a new role if they are up to date in their skills, particularly in the technology area," she says.

"For anyone in a professional role, it's essential to be on LinkedIn and have an interesting and compelling profile."

Emotions around redundancy

McShane says one of the biggest considerations around redundancy is the mindset.

"People think about the numbers but not the mindset - what's the feeling about the whole situation, are you ready and what's your next chapter?" says McShane.

"People sometimes don't stop and think about the broader aspects - they might like the idea about the money but don't think about how they might feel, particularly if they're getting close to retirement."

He says some people don't have the money they wanted to retire with but they are over their job and burnt out from the job, so they've made it work and are happy; others have had plenty of money, took an early retirement but didn't know what to do with themselves and ended up miserable.

"The best scenario is often to have another job or career lined up - not somewhere just because you need a job but somewhere you wanted to go," says McShane.

"He says what throws a spanner in the works now is that we have exceptional circumstances, which might make people make different decisions than in normal times.

"For example, people who have the opportunity of a payout at Qantas might choose to take it to stop the uncertainty facing that industry right now - they may be prepared to take the risk and try something new."

Get stories like this in our newsletters.

Related Stories

Julia Newbould is one of the hosts of the Friends With Money podcast. She was previously editor of Financial Planning and Super Review magazines; managing editor at InvestorInfo and at Morningstar Australia. Julia co-authored The Joy of Money, a book on women and personal finance. She holds a Bachelor of Economics from the University of Sydney where she serves on the alumni council.
Not My Real Name
August 26, 2020 8.37pm

Would prefer my real name is not used.

Recently went through a "faux voluntary redundancy" where our employer put out for expressions of interest with a 2 year completion time frame to lose X number of employees. I put in for it as did many others but made the fatal mistake of ticking the 2 yrs box to go thinking this would give me more time to save, mentally prepare and organise my possible retirement. Halfway through this process we got a new manager who reversed the decision to allow redundancies and actually started hiring again. This, after 20 or more people had already gone and already taken hundreds of thousands in payouts.

Boy did that screw with my head as I had mentally gone into retirement mode, had got advice, planned how to invest my windfall and was keen to go. Looks like I will be working there for a lot longer now. Not happy Jan.

Tip- take any redundancy offer ASAP.

Also I have never had any luck with Linked In, it spams all your contacts, and makes you just a little bit unpopular for that reason, plus more spam from irrelevant overseas members of that app that are really only trying to get work in Australia and are usually not in the same industry and don't seem to actually have any experience

Leeanne Abrahams
August 27, 2020 6.51pm

I worked for a large company for 20 years. The company did not have an issue with my work. In April this year the new manager decided to make us all redundant. 42 of us. All while the COVID 19 was happening. Yes I got an involuntary redundancy but I have to live off it until it's all gone. Im single. I have a a big mortgage and not many working years left. Management didn't care. Can't even get Jobseeker or any help finding a job because you have to be getting a centrelink payments before you get help. Redundancy payment wasn't worth it. Too many younger people out there because of covid at the moment looking for jobs. I will have to sell my home now. In my experience single over 60's seem to miss out on any support going around.

Further Reading